Purchasing a used car can be both exciting and nerve-wracking. For many buyers, a used car offers a more affordable way to get on the road, but it also comes with certain risks. Chief among them is the potential for defects in critical components, especially the engine. Since the engine is essentially the heart of any vehicle, issues with it can lead to serious performance problems, safety risks, and, often, expensive repairs. For those who discover engine defects shortly after buying a used car, it’s natural to feel overwhelmed and wonder what protections they have.

Engine problems, like recurring stalls, power loss, and overheating, aren’t just inconvenient—they can render the car unusable or unsafe. California’s Lemon Law, while commonly associated with new vehicles, also offers protections for certain used cars, particularly those sold with a warranty. The law can require the dealer or manufacturer to repair, replace, or repurchase defective vehicles, provided they meet specific criteria.

How California’s Lemon Law Applies to Used Cars

California’s Lemon Law, officially known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, is designed to protect consumers who purchase or lease defective vehicles. While it’s often associated with new cars, California’s Lemon Law extends to certain used vehicles as well, provided they meet specific criteria. If a vehicle is deemed a “lemon” under the law, the manufacturer or dealer may be required to repair, replace, or repurchase it, offering vital protection to consumers stuck with a defective vehicle.

Coverage for Used Vehicles

In California, the Lemon Law applies not only to new vehicles but also to certain used cars. However, for a used car to qualify, it must be sold with an active warranty. This includes:

• Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Vehicles: These vehicles often come with a manufacturer-backed warranty that covers specific repairs within a set time frame.
• Used Cars Sold with Dealer Warranties: Some dealerships offer limited warranties on their used vehicles, providing coverage for particular issues or repairs for a defined period after purchase.

For used cars with any of these warranties, buyers can pursue a Lemon Law claim if the vehicle experiences recurring issues that meet the law’s criteria. This added layer of protection is particularly helpful for buyers of certified pre-owned or dealer-warrantied used cars, as it ensures they aren’t left responsible for unresolved, costly defects that should have been covered by the seller.

Engine Defects as a Qualifying Issue

Engine defects are among the most serious types of vehicle problems due to their impact on safety, reliability, and performance. Under California’s Lemon Law, engine defects typically meet the threshold for a claim, as they can:

• Impact Safety: Engine issues, such as stalling, sudden power loss, or overheating, pose safety risks for drivers and passengers, especially on busy highways or in challenging driving conditions.
• Affect Usability: A car that cannot operate reliably is hardly usable for daily commuting, errands, or longer trips. Engine problems can render the vehicle undependable and unsuitable for regular use.
• Reduce Vehicle Value: Recurring engine issues significantly diminish a car’s resale or trade-in value, as they signal an ongoing problem that can deter future buyers.

Recognizing Common Engine Defects in Used Cars

Unusual Noises and Vibrations

Strange sounds or vibrations coming from the engine area are often the first signs of trouble. Common noises to watch for include:

• Knocking or Pinging Sounds: A knocking noise, especially when accelerating, can indicate issues with the engine’s combustion process, which may stem from worn-out components like spark plugs or connecting rods.
• Vibrations: Excessive vibrations while idling or accelerating can suggest issues with engine mounts or imbalances in the engine’s moving parts.
• Backfiring or Sputtering: These sounds may result from problems with the engine’s fuel or exhaust systems, often signaling that the engine isn’t burning fuel correctly.

Oil Leaks and Smoke

Visible signs of engine trouble, like oil leaks and smoke from the exhaust, often indicate severe issues that need immediate attention.

• Oil Leaks: Oil leaks are a common sign of engine trouble, often due to worn gaskets, seals, or oil pans. If left unaddressed, leaks can lead to low oil levels, causing further engine damage from lack of lubrication.
• Smoke from the Exhaust: Smoke, especially if it’s blue or white, can signal major engine issues. Blue smoke typically means oil is burning in the engine, which can stem from worn piston rings or valves. White smoke may indicate a coolant leak, which can lead to overheating and further engine problems.

Check Engine Light

The check engine light is one of the most recognizable indicators of engine problems, and it shouldn’t be ignored.

• Persistent Check Engine Light: If the check engine light remains on after multiple repairs, it may indicate an underlying issue that has not been properly addressed.
• Frequent Illumination: A check engine light that keeps coming on, especially shortly after repairs, suggests a recurring problem that could indicate a defective vehicle. Common causes include sensor issues, fuel system problems, or engine misfires.

Power Loss or Stalling

Performance issues like power loss and stalling are serious symptoms of engine trouble that affect the vehicle’s drivability and safety.

• Power Loss: If the vehicle struggles to accelerate or loses power unexpectedly, it may have issues with fuel injection, ignition, or the transmission. This not only limits performance but also raises safety concerns, particularly when driving in traffic. Learn more about engine defects under California’s Lemon Law.
• Difficulty Starting or Frequent Stalling: An engine that stalls or has trouble starting can indicate serious problems with fuel delivery, ignition timing, or airflow. Frequent stalling can make the car unreliable and unsafe for regular use.

Steps to Take if You Suspect Engine Defects in a Used Car

Document All Repair Attempts

Thorough documentation is one of the most critical elements of a successful lemon law claim. Detailed records of each repair attempt not only show that you made an effort to resolve the issue but also demonstrate the recurring nature of the problem if it persists.

• Record Dates and Details: Note the date of each visit to the repair shop, the specific issues reported, and any repair work performed. This timeline can be invaluable in showing how long the defect has been a problem.
• Keep All Repair Orders and Receipts: Ask the service provider for a detailed repair order or receipt for each visit, showing the work performed, any parts replaced, and any notes from the technician.
• Track Outcomes: Record whether each repair resolved the issue, provided only a temporary fix, or failed to address the problem altogether. This pattern of recurring issues is crucial in building a California Lemon Law case.

Notify the Dealer or Manufacturer Promptly

As soon as you notice signs of engine trouble, contact the dealer or manufacturer. Promptly reporting issues and seeking formal repairs shows that you’re actively attempting to address the problem, and it creates an official record of the defect.

• Contact the Dealer for Initial Repairs: If the vehicle was purchased with a warranty from the dealer, contact them first and schedule a repair appointment. Make sure to describe the issue clearly and request a thorough diagnosis.
• Report Issues to the Manufacturer if Necessary: If the dealer is unable to resolve the problem, consider contacting the manufacturer directly, especially if the vehicle is still covered by a manufacturer warranty. This can add weight to your claim by showing that you sought assistance at multiple levels.
• Document All Communications: Keep a log of phone calls, emails, and in-person conversations related to the defect. Include details such as dates, names of representatives, and a summary of what was discussed. These records help establish a timeline and confirm your attempts to resolve the issue.

Get a Third-Party Inspection

In cases where the dealer or manufacturer’s repairs haven’t resolved the engine defect, a third-party inspection can be invaluable. An independent mechanic can provide an objective assessment of the problem, confirming its presence and severity.

• Seek an Experienced Mechanic: Choose a mechanic who specializes in the type of vehicle you own or has a strong reputation in diagnosing engine issues. A qualified third-party inspection can reveal underlying problems that may have been missed by the dealer.
• Request a Detailed Report: Ask the mechanic for a written report detailing the defect, any diagnostic findings, and recommendations for repair. This report can serve as crucial evidence in your Lemon Law claim, showing the defect remains unresolved despite prior attempts.
• Document the Cost of Inspection: If you paid out-of-pocket for the third-party inspection, keep the receipt, as this expense may be recoverable as part of your claim if the vehicle qualifies as a lemon.

Options for Resolution Under California’s Lemon Law

Repair of the Defect

Under California’s Lemon Law, the dealer or manufacturer is initially required to make reasonable attempts to repair the defect. When you report an engine issue, the dealer or manufacturer must assess and try to fix the problem within the warranty period.

• Reasonable Number of Repair Attempts: The Lemon Law requires that the dealer or manufacturer make a reasonable number of attempts to repair the defect. While there is no strict number, usually two to four repair attempts are considered reasonable, especially if the defect poses a safety risk.
• Persistent Problems: If the engine defect remains unresolved despite these efforts, you may then pursue additional remedies under the Lemon Law, including replacement, buyback, or compensation.

Documenting each repair attempt is crucial in demonstrating that the dealer or manufacturer was given sufficient opportunity to resolve the defect, which strengthens your lemon law claim if repairs fail.

Replacement Vehicle

If repairs do not resolve the engine issue, you may be entitled to a replacement vehicle. This option is ideal for consumers who want a comparable vehicle without the same defects.

• Comparable Replacement: Under the Lemon Law, the dealer or manufacturer is required to offer a replacement vehicle that matches the original in terms of model, features, and condition. This allows you to continue driving a similar car without the burden of persistent engine issues.
• Fresh Warranty: The replacement vehicle will typically come with a new warranty, giving you peace of mind and protecting you from similar issues in the future.

A replacement is a practical solution for those who want to stay with the same type of vehicle while ensuring reliability and performance.

Vehicle Buyback

If a replacement vehicle is not suitable or desired, California’s Lemon Law allows for a vehicle buyback. In this scenario, the dealer or manufacturer repurchases the defective vehicle, providing a refund that covers various costs.

• Refunded Purchase Price: The buyback includes the original purchase price, along with taxes, registration fees, and certain financing charges.
• Usage Fee Deduction: California’s Lemon Law permits the manufacturer to deduct a “usage fee” based on the miles driven before the defect was first reported. This deduction is standardized, ensuring fairness.
• Complete Separation from the Vehicle: A buyback offers a clean break from the defective vehicle, allowing you to use the refund to purchase another car without worrying about recurring issues.

The buyback option is ideal for consumers who prefer to move on from the vehicle entirely and avoid future risk of defects.

Financial Compensation

In certain cases, instead of a replacement or buyback, consumers may receive financial compensation to offset the expenses and inconvenience caused by the defect.

• Repair Cost Reimbursement: If you incurred out-of-pocket expenses for repairs or diagnostic inspections, financial compensation may cover these costs.
• Compensation for Diminished Value: If the engine defect has reduced the vehicle’s resale or trade-in value, you may receive compensation to account for this loss.
• Other Incidental Costs: In some cases, you may be reimbursed for additional expenses, such as rental car fees incurred while your vehicle was in the shop.

Financial compensation is a good option if the defect has impacted the vehicle’s value or caused substantial inconvenience, but you’re otherwise willing to keep the car.

Conclusion

Engine defects are among the most serious issues a car owner can face, impacting safety, performance, and the vehicle’s overall reliability. For buyers of used cars with warranties, California’s Lemon Law provides essential protections, ensuring that you don’t have to deal with recurring engine problems alone.

Whether your vehicle requires multiple repair attempts, a replacement, a buyback, or even financial compensation, California’s Lemon Law offers a pathway to fair resolutions if the dealer or manufacturer cannot resolve the defect.

If you’ve purchased a used car with a warranty and are dealing with recurring engine issues, Contact California Lemon Daddy for a free consultation. Our experienced team can help you understand your rights, navigate the Lemon Law claim process, and work toward a fair resolution. Reach out today, and let us handle the legal complexities so you can focus on finding a safe, reliable vehicle.

Contact California Lemon Daddy:
Phone: (888) 242-9392
Email: Lemon@drakelawgroup.com
Website: www.lemondaddy.com

‍