‍

While new cars are expected to be reliable and trouble-free, it’s not uncommon for vehicles to experience mechanical issues, electrical malfunctions, or safety system failures that affect their performance and usability. When these problems persist despite repair attempts, it can leave car owners feeling overwhelmed, inconvenienced, and stuck with a vehicle they can’t depend on.

What Qualifies Your New Car as a Lemon in Thousand Oaks?

Under California Lemon Law, a vehicle is considered a lemon if it has a substantial defect that affects its safety, performance, or value, and the manufacturer is unable to fix the issue after a reasonable number of repair attempts. A substantial defect could be anything from a malfunctioning brake system that makes the vehicle unsafe to drive, to an engine issue that prevents the car from operating as intended. Minor problems, such as cosmetic defects or small inconveniences, do not typically qualify under Lemon Law, but if the issue makes the car unreliable or unsafe, it may meet the criteria.

Number of Repair Attempts

For a vehicle to qualify as a lemon, the manufacturer must be given a “reasonable number of repair attempts” to resolve the issue. Generally, this means:

• 2–4 attempts: If the manufacturer or authorized dealership has made 2–4 attempts to fix the same defect, and the problem persists, the vehicle may be considered a lemon.
• Safety-related defects: For defects that pose a significant safety risk, fewer repair attempts may be needed before the vehicle qualifies as a lemon.

Out of Service Time

Another important factor in determining whether your car qualifies as a lemon is the amount of time it has been out of service due to the defect. Under California Lemon Law:

• If your vehicle has been in the repair shop for a total of 30 days or more, whether consecutive or spread out over multiple repair attempts, it may qualify as a lemon.
• Even if the defect isn’t resolved after numerous repairs, the extended time out of service can strengthen your case for a Lemon Law claim.

Immediate Steps to Take if Your Car Is Defective

Keep Detailed Records

If you suspect that your new car is defective, one of the most important things you can do is document everything. Keeping thorough records will not only help you keep track of the repair process but will also be critical if you decide to file a Lemon Law claim. Here are the key things to document:

• Repair attempts: Write down every time you take your car in for repairs, including the date, the specific issue being addressed, and what the dealership or repair shop did to fix it.
• Service receipts: Keep all receipts and invoices for repair work, even if the repairs were covered under warranty. These records show that you gave the manufacturer a reasonable opportunity to fix the defect.
• Communication with the dealership or manufacturer: Save copies of any emails, text messages, or other correspondence with the dealership or manufacturer. This can be used as evidence that you notified the manufacturer about the issue and that they were aware of the problem.

Give the Manufacturer a Chance to Repair

Under California Lemon Law, the manufacturer must be given a reasonable chance to repair the defect before your vehicle can qualify as a lemon. This means you need to return the car to the dealership or authorized repair shop for multiple attempts to resolve the issue. Here’s what you need to know:

• Return the car for repairs: As soon as you notice the defect, take your vehicle to the dealership or repair shop authorized by the manufacturer. Make sure they are aware of the specific issue and document each visit.
• Track each repair attempt: Keep a log of how many times the car has been in the shop for the same problem, as well as how long the vehicle was out of service during each repair attempt. Under Lemon Law, the manufacturer is typically given 2–4 repair attempts before the vehicle qualifies as a lemon.
• Request documentation: Each time you take your vehicle in for repairs, request detailed documentation that lists what was done to address the defect.

Manufacturer's Responsibilities

Under California Lemon Law, manufacturers have specific obligations when dealing with defective vehicles. They are required to provide a reasonable number of repair attempts to address substantial defects that impair the vehicle’s safety, performance, or value. Here’s what that means:

• Prompt response: Once you notify the manufacturer of the defect, they must respond promptly and begin the repair process without unnecessary delays. The repair attempts must be carried out within a reasonable timeframe to meet their legal responsibilities.
• Timely repairs: Manufacturers are obligated to make genuine efforts to fix the issue within a reasonable number of attempts—typically 2 to 4 tries—depending on the severity of the defect. For safety-related issues, fewer attempts may be necessary.
• Warranty-backed repairs: If your vehicle is under warranty, the manufacturer must cover the cost of repairs to ensure the defect is fixed.

When the Manufacturer Refuses

If the manufacturer fails to meet their legal obligations or refuses to resolve the issue after multiple repair attempts, you may need to pursue legal action. In this case, you should consider:

• Filing a Lemon Law claim: By working with a qualified Lemon Law attorney, you can file a claim against the manufacturer to enforce your rights. Attorneys can help you gather the necessary documentation, handle negotiations, and ensure the manufacturer complies with Lemon Law requirements.
• Taking legal recourse: If negotiations fail, your attorney may take the case to court to secure a refund, replacement, or compensation on your behalf.

When to File a Lemon Law Claim

Knowing When to File

If your vehicle’s defect persists after a reasonable number of repair attempts—typically 2 to 4—or if it has spent an extended period (usually 30 days or more) in the shop due to repairs, it’s time to consider filing a Lemon Law claim. Here’s how to determine if it’s time to move forward:

• Unresolved defects: If the defect affects your car’s safety, performance, or value, and multiple repair attempts have failed to fix the problem, your car may qualify as a lemon.
• Out of service time: Even if the defect is minor, if your vehicle has been out of service for an extended period—usually 30 days or more—it may qualify as a lemon under California law. Keeping a detailed log of how long your car has been in the repair shop is crucial to your case.
• Multiple defects: If your car has several unrelated defects that repeatedly require repairs, it may also qualify as a lemon, even if each individual defect might not be enough to warrant a claim.

Consulting a Lemon Law Attorney

Navigating a Lemon Law claim can be complex, which is why consulting a Lemon Law attorney is highly recommended. Here’s why working with an attorney is beneficial:

• Understanding the law: Lemon Law has specific requirements and deadlines that can be challenging to manage. An experienced attorney can help you understand California Lemon Law and how it applies to your specific situation.
• Building a strong case: Attorneys know what documentation is required to build a solid Lemon Law case. They will help you organize your repair records, communication with the manufacturer, and any other evidence needed to support your claim.
• Handling negotiations: If your manufacturer is reluctant to resolve the issue, a Lemon Law attorney can negotiate on your behalf to secure a refund, replacement vehicle, or monetary compensation.
• Maximizing your outcome: Working with a Lemon Law attorney ensures you get the best possible outcome, whether that’s a full refund, a new car, or financial compensation.

Potential Outcomes if You Have a Lemon

If your new car qualifies as a lemon under California Lemon Law, there are a few potential outcomes that the manufacturer may offer:

• Refund:some text
  • The manufacturer may be required to refund the full purchase price of the vehicle. This typically includes not only the cost of the car but also taxes, registration fees, and any other incidental costs related to the purchase.
• Replacement Vehicle:some text
  • In some cases, the manufacturer may offer a replacement vehicle. This would be a car of the same model or a comparable model that meets the customer’s needs. If you choose a replacement vehicle, the terms must be favorable to you.
• Monetary Compensation:some text
  • If a full refund or replacement isn’t feasible, the manufacturer may offer financial compensation. This can cover the cost of ongoing repairs, diminished vehicle value, or even a partial refund based on how long you’ve had the car and how much you’ve used it.

Take Action if Your New Car Is a Lemon in Thousand Oaks

If your new car in Thousand Oaks is showing signs of being a lemon, contact Lemon Daddy for a free case evaluation. Our experienced attorneys will guide you through the Lemon Law process and fight for the compensation or replacement vehicle you deserve. Call us at (888) 242-9392 or visit www.lemondaddy.com to get started today.

‍